The collapse of a breakaway European league via a flawed announcement threw serious shade on some of Europe’s biggest football clubs, so what did they get so wrong?
The main issue was that the new league was solving a problem for the clubs (companies) and not the fans (consumers).
The situation was a textbook example of failing to understand market needs.
Looking at this from a marketing perspective, it is clear to see that the people involved had failed to get solid foundations in place. There appeared to be little to no market awareness or understanding, and this had a huge impact.
The plans were described in the media as treating ‘legacy fans’ with contempt. And this level of contempt created immediate resistance and noise, with fans taking to the streets and social media to voice their dismay.
Solving a problem for your company without consulting your consumers, particularly where the problem is focussed on your profits can lead to huge problems. Your entire marketing strategy could be infiltrated throwing shade on all of your other activities.
What could have been done differently?
The very simply answer is that the companies should have listened to their customers.
In addition to listening there are some simple marketing basics that could have delivered a different outcome…
Research is vital and in this instance, it seems it was overlooked or undervalued with huge consequences. Some of the clubs involved in the scheme engaged in some level of market research by engaging with their fan forums. However, this appears to have been superficial and therefore delivered negative consequences.
Lessons in listening
Marketers are hard-wired to listen to their customers. By taking the time to listen you open up the possibility to solve problems for everyone. You generate awareness, build empathy, and grow your understanding.
The new super league appeared to target new and younger fan bases on a global level. Okay fine a new potential market is identified, and plans were shared to alter match timings to offer a better fit with different time zones.
So, what about your existing, large, dedicated fan base? What problem are you solving for them? The proposal instantly alienated around 4 Billion football fans worldwide!
Following the announcement, news streams were filled with fans and pundits discussing their dismay. Many fans also took to the streets and congregated outside stadiums united in their rejection of the league. Covid prevented larger in-person protests, but angry fans were still able to make their voices heard and caused disruption and delays at matches following the announcement.
YouGov also reported significant % drops in positive sentiment values towards the clubs involved and fans rallied across social media to share their negative perceptions.
Clubs excluded from the proposed league also joined the conversation and the stories profile grew quickly moving from Sports News to Headline News and earning headlines across the world.
The situation caused embarrassment for those involved, left threats of sanctions hanging over them and clubs reeled as their billionaire owners and investors scrambled to apologise to their fanbases.
Content & messaging
Content remains king and companies can live, and die based on their messaging.
The official press release announcing the league was littered with the wrong kind of key words. Fans didn’t take well to reading about “finances”, “economics”, “revenues” and “commercials”.
The narrative was out of step with the fans and therefore the messaging used to announce the league left audiences with a poor impression and a focus on greed.
No matter how great your product is, if your messaging is poor your audience won’t ‘buy it’.
Comms in crisis – remember the 7 P’s
Making a bad situation worse, the clubs deployed a comms plan that simply didn’t work.
At marketing’s core you’ll find the traditional 7 P’s – Product, Price, Promotion, Place/Plan, People, Process and Physical Evidence.
In the case of the super league proposal all 7 P’s were flawed:
Product – solving a problem for companies and not consumers, no-one asked for or wanted the product
Price – the customers were already unhappy with current pricing & unable to stomach increases
Promotion – the announcement was limited to a cold press release with the wrong messaging
Place/Plan – the plan was under research and unclear
People – the only people in ‘the know’ were club owners (fans, managers & stakeholders were in the dark)
Process – the process was overlooked and was not customer friendly
Physical Evidence – the experience left a bad taste and damaged reputations
Internal comms is too often overlooked and undervalued. In this case it could not be more critical!
It seems clear that the only people in ‘the know’ about the plans were the owners. Leaving Managers, players, and club staff to perhaps find out about the announcement hours/minutes before it was made.
Hung out to dry in post-match interviews, with no briefing or messaging some players and managers refused to comment, whilst others spoke out against the plans.
This instantly created a dominant narrative of confusion, total lack of transparency and caused embarrassment to figureheads who were left to confirm that they were finding out at the same time as the public.
If Managers and players thought that they had it rough official bodies were also left in the dark. This lack of engagement led to a senior post holder at UEFA calling a club executive a “snake” in the media.
The Premier League and FIFA then threatened any player taking part in the league would face instant expulsion from international competitions.
Instead of this all playing out in public it could have been avoided with planned, clear dialogue.
Engaging with stakeholders, listening to them and getting them on board, before making a public announcement would lead to a very different and more positive outcome.
Top-5 Lessons to take away:
1. Do your research
2. Listen to your customers/audiences and segment them accordingly
3. Consider your reputational impact
4. Communicate clearly & align your messaging to your tactics
5. Engage with your audiences – value internal comms and stakeholder engagement